I hate worrying, don’t you?
Every now and again I run across people in the handmade blogging/consulting arena who make me anxious. Even if our audiences are different and I have no reason to really worry, I often feel nervous and think things like:
I wish I had a better layout on my blog
Why is their traffic so much higher than mine
I wish people were buzzing about my website too
Now, the only way to overcome these feelings is to sit down and take a hard look at their business.
The reasons you want to analyze your competitors is to see:
- What they are doing right.
- Things they are doing wrong.
- The items selling best for them.
- Where they’ve been featured and for what.
- What people are buzzing most about.
Then you can come up with serious ways to CRUSH IT and create your own handmade fame.
4 Simple Ways to Crush Your Handmade Competitors
Tip #1 – Make yourself unique.
What makes you and/or your products different from your competitors? If you don’t know, you need to come up with something to set yourself apart. To me, making yourself unique really boils down to one question:
Who Wants to Buy Your Products?
If you are selling to everyone, narrow that down NOW. Three Examples:
- You and your competitors sell handmade soap which is for ‘everyone’. You decide to make yourself different by only making soap for men. You would change your fragrance list and color scheme then start marketing your new brand accordingly. Not only will you be ‘different’ from your competitors, you will start being remembered as the ‘handmade soap company just for men’. Stuff like that spreads fast.
Now one thing to consider is that “men” is a big category. You can take this down another few notches and create a niche for yourself that is easy to market and create a buzz for. Most men are very different. Some like like sports, some that hate them. Men who like cars, men who are eco it up on the streetcar. Young men, old men. Gaming men and Working Men.
- Say you sell handmade cards. If you only want to sell online but that means trying to sell cards among a lot of crafty people. So you decide to change things up and create a bunch of ‘card making kits’. These kits are aimed at crafty kids so now all the crafty people are snapping them up. Now you are the Crafty Kids Card Kit Company and you are an instant hit.
- What if you are a jewelry designer? You want to appeal to brides because that’s where the big money is but you are consistently being beaten in sales by competitor shops. You decide to do something crazy and start targeting “Eco-Brides”. You start sourcing all of your material locally and incorporate recycled pieces as well. You even create a line featuring live grass that has to be watered. Now you’re unique AND in the money!
Tip #2 – Improve your photos.
After being unique, your photos are the biggest factor in success. When you sell online, noone can physically touch or examine your pieces so you need to show them exactly how they look by snapping photos that will give buyers a real sense of what they are about to purchase.
This is going to sound harsh. You KNOW if your photos stink. I don’t care how old you are or how inexperienced you are. If you want to take awful shots and then talk about them as being ‘not bad’ then just forget online selling. Not bad won’t get you sales regardless of how damn unique you are. There are endless resources out there to help you improve your photos but let’s start with the most simple factors:
- Buy a new camera
If you are using a camera you got 5 years ago, it’s time for an upgrade. If you aren’t sure about investing in a new camera you could borrow a few from different friends and family to see which one produces the best results. I spent a month researching the best camera for my business.
- Practice makes perfect
I hate saying this but it’s true. I snapped a minimum of 30 shots PER item until I found 5 quality photos to use on Etsy. Some days I couldn’t even 5 good ones and had to snap another 30 per item. As time went on, I just took 5 shots per product and all of them were perfect.
- Use common sense
Would you want to buy a brand new book from Amazon that is snapped on top of someone’s bed. That’s just weird. What if it was on top of a wood floor. Not professional. It doesn’t matter if this is your home business, you need to go for a clean look for all of your photos.
- Do your homework
Back to the endless resources available. Read up on tips and actually TAKE ACTION on them.
Tip #3 – Offer something they don’t.
You know your business well so you will examine competitors and easily identify things you consider ‘flaws’. Use your competitors weak points to enhance your own business. For instance, say they only offer made to order items. You will start busting your butt to create a selection of ready made items, shipped out within 1 business day. Or what if they charge $5 for gift wrapping. Now you will start offering complimentary gift wrapping (which you can factor into your prices to ensure you aren’t losing a dime).
Where do you look for these flaws?
- Their website
- In their shop photos and listing descriptions
- In their blogs & social sites
- In their advertising
Tip #4 – Be Everywhere and then some.
The best part about social media is there are so many people still unwilling to try. That means some of your competitors may not be on Twitter or Facebook yet. Get on there are start spreading the word about what YOU offer before they do. By the time they get on there, you will already be 10 steps ahead.
It’s still very likely that the other half of your competitors are already using social sites. No biggie. Use the same ‘examining technique’ to determine their social media weaknesses. There’s a damn good chance they are just tweeting their own links so since you just read up on how not to be annoying on Twitter, you know how to use Twitter more effectively which makes your brand more likable and your success more favorable.
One last thought: Once you have worked on tips 1, 2 & 3 you will need to actively and aggressively promote yourself because noone will know about your great UNIQUE brand but you.
The bottom line is there are endless ways to stand out from the crowd but these 4 tips are the easiest and most successful ways to really kick things up a notch. If you found this post helpful be sure to leave a comment and tweet this post by clicking on the ‘retweet’ button at the top of the post!
Soda Can Pic courtesy of John Linwood

I'm Justine Smith, a Toronto Social Media Consultant, Problogger & Sales Strategist. I can help you dominate your creative business and build the success you've always dreamed of. To learn more, click 



I think something else to remember is that, in most cases, your competitors are worried about the same things. It’s human nature. There’s always going to be someone bigger, better than us, but worrying doesn’t get you anywhere. I agree, it’s all about action.
Justine, I think you’re completely right. There are a TON of talented people out there trying to sell handmade things and art. Unless your stuff is unique AND well-promoted, you’re going to get lost in the crowd.
I have a tip for your readers that recently worked for me. I took my artwork out of its normal context and displayed it in a completely unique way (and took a good picture of it). That got me a very nice mention a few days ago in Apartment Therapy’s re-nest blog. Here’s the link: http://www.re-nest.com/re-nest/diy/diy-inspiration-rustic-art-display-by-brenda-biondo-108704
.-= Biondo Brenda´s last blog ..Botanical Photograph 12.3 X 18.2 Limited Edition =-.
thank you once again for actionable information….I was feeling overwhelmed by technology, but you have given me some action I can take. Thank you once again!!!
.-= Robyn Colledge´s last blog ..Grandpa’s pride and joy frame =-.
Thank you Justin for the info. I have to say that I think I have done what you mentioned but maybe I need to re-evaluate my efforts.
I will keep you posted. Thanks again
.-= Ardlee Simon´s last blog ..Hand Painted–Eat-Sleep-Poop =-.
[...] 4 Ways to Crush Your Handmade Competitors | Handmade Marketer [...]
I think it’s also important to know that whenever you launch a new product, it takes a bit of time for people to recieve it, especially when your product isn’t the “cutesy” or generic looking.
When I was doing my hand carved stamps, it took some time for people to really start getting interested.
Now, I’m going through the same with my hand bound journals and sketchbooks.
Thanks for the ideas—I’m going to take 5 minutes right now to check out the competition. If I keep saying “I’ll do that later when I have more time”, it’s not going to get done.
Love reading your newsletters!!
Lisa
I can instantly think of 2 things to improve……..thanks Justine
.-= Pat Sechos´s last blog ..Amethyst and White Polka Dot Angel =-.
I love this! I’m not a competitive type by nature, but I have had to face facts that if you want to have, you need to stand out, know your market, and promote. Oh, and the photos…yes, I still take quite a few to get that 5. My rule (that I don’t always follow, oops) is that it should get me in the gut. If I don’t feel it, who will? Great article!
.-= Jennifer´s last blog ..The Pretenders, Racer back, Sweater Dress, Limited Edition =-.
Justine,
Great post. Love your creative ideas. Keep up the good work!!
Thank you Justine! I have seen things in a new light if you will. I have a lot of work ahead of me now. Thank you so much for your insight and helping us to identify what is wrong with our shops!
Thanks Again,
SkyleRae
I know feel I’m on the right track! Lately, I’ve been reading competitors store announcements, shipping prices, and over all items. Then asking how can I use what I’ve seen and or make it better for my customers. Thank you for the article, love this blog ; )
.-= Melanie Morales´s last blog ..Circus in Montreal. =-.
Awesome Justine! Thanks.
I can so relate to the taking 30 pics to get 5 good ones. I have been retaking and reposting pics on my site like crazy. My first ones were so crumby.
I wonder if you’d take a look at my shop and give me a critique?
Thanks,
Audrey
AudreyGardenLady at etsy
.-= Audrey´s last blog ..Sassy Copper Hoops =-.
Justine – you hit the nail on the head in this article. Such practical tips that make so much sense, it’s just a matter of putting them into practice. Thank you!
I spend time each day viewing my competitors websites and see what I can improve in my own shop. This is a great artical with alot of helpful tips. I am still in the process of improving my photos. Thank you:)
.-= Destinys Treasures´s last blog ..Shamrock Catnip Toy =-.
Thanks Justine for yet another great article. I’m ready for a new camera, my scanner is my photo guru right now. The pics are okay, but I can do better.
.-= Jennifer Schulting´s last blog ..DJ Dog Handmade Greeting Card =-.
Thank you so much for this post!
I am just starting my business so these are great things to know!
You manage to set yourself aside with these ever so
practical tips. You’ve given me much food for thought.
I love you display on DIY…..u r so clever : )
This feeling is not limited to hand made stuff.
Probably everyone feels it.
Every couple of weeks I run across someone “new” and I’m like “WTH? Where did they come from? And why are they stealing all my traffic!?”
Your point about being everywhere is really good. It’s also really hard, because I don’t count using automated social media tools as part of “campaign everywhere.” I can usually tell when there isn’t anyone behind the traffic, and it doesn’t really make me want to click through.
.-= Dave Doolin´s last blog ..Red Shoe Blogger Follows Yellow Brick Road And Finds: No Wizard. No Oz. No Magic. No Message. =-.
Excellent advice. Thanks for the reminder about social media. I get so caught up in finding new places to promote that I forget about my Facebook account.

.-= Annabelle´s last blog ..Granny Square Crochet – How to Crochet a Basic Square =-.